Skip to content
  • About Us
  • News & Insights
  • Member Directory
  • Job Board
  • Sign In
  • Join
Home > Community News > Broker-Dealer Rule Triggers Clash on Beacon Hill
Boston Chamber
  • Become a Member
        • Become a Member

          • Overview
          • Membership Benefits
          • Membership Levels
          • Member Stories
          • Request a Meeting
          • Join Today
        • ...
          About Us
          Get to Know the Chamber

          Discover our mission, values, and leadership.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Member Benefits
          Grow Your Business

          Explore benefits that power your success.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Membership Directory
          Not sure if you’re a member?

          Browse our network of businesses.

          arrow-go
          Read More
  • Events & Networking
        • Events & Networking

          • Overview
          • Upcoming Events
          • Limited Series
          • Chamber Awards
          • Foundation Initiatives
          • FIFA World Cup 2026™
          • Tall Ships – Sail250 
          • MA250  
        • WHAT’S NEXT

          ...
          Upcoming Events
          Engage & Learn

          Explore opportunities to connect and grow.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • FEATURED EVENT

          ...
          Public Policy
          2026 Government Affairs Forum | Ronald J. Mariano, Massachusetts Speaker of the House

          Hear from the Massachusetts Speaker of the House, Representative Ronald J. Mariano (D-Quincy), at the Chamber’s Government Affairs Forum.

          04/09/2026

          9:45am - 11:00am

          Fairmont Copley Plaza Boston

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • EXPLORE OUR PROGRAMMING:

          • Annual & Premier Events
          • Economic Inclusion
          • Small Business & Entrepreneurship
          • Digital Media & Marketing
          • Public Policy
          • Professional Development
          • Women’s Network
          • Workforce Development
          • Young Professionals Network
          • VIEW ALL PROGRAMMING
  • Member Engagement
        • Member Engagement

          • Member Resources
          • Member Deals
          • Sponsorship Opportunities
          • Small Business Benefits
          • Connect with your Member Services Rep
          • Member Spotlights
          • Sign In
        • ...
          Maximize Your Membership
          Register Now

          Take advantage of exclusive perks and programs for members.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Membership Directory
          Discover fellow Chamber members.

          Browse our directory to find and connect with member community.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Upcoming Events
          Stay Involved

          Join experiences that build relationships and spark ideas.

          arrow-go
          Read More
  • Talent & Workforce
        • Talent & Workforce

          • Professional Development
          • Workforce Development
          • Open Programs
          • Insights
        • WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT (FOUNDATION) PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
          City Awake

          City Awake empowers young professionals in a variety of ways that encourages these rising leaders to stay invested in the region’s future success.

          Read More
          Management Crash Course: Core Skills for Modern Supervisors

          Boost your leadership skills with this three‑module professional development series covering adaptive supervision, conflict management, and inclusive decision‑making — with a Certificate of Completion for those who finish the full program.

          Read More
          Massachusetts Apprentice Network

          The Massachusetts Apprentice Network convenes employers, training providers, and talent sources interested in developing and implementing apprenticeship programs in occupations across industries and statewide in fields such as tech, advanced manufacturing, healthcare, financial services, and more.

          Read More
          Strategic Communication for Better Collaboration

          Level up your leadership and communication in this Boston Chamber workshop for professionals—gain essential skills in team alignment.

          Read More
          Partnership with Boston Public Schools 

          The Chamber Foundation invites the business community to engage with Boston Public Schools leaders and their students to help build the future workforce.

          Read More
          Women’s Leadership Program

          Our Women’s Leadership Program enables you to take your leadership to the next level by arming you with the most in-demand leadership toolkit.

          Read More
  • Policy & Impact
        • Policy & Impact

          • Overview
          • Leadership Councils
          • Amicus Advisory Board
          • Government Affairs Forum
          • Eds & Meds Report
        • GET INVOLVED IN OUR POLICY FOCUS AREAS

          Business Climate
          Read More
          Climate & Energy
          Read More
          Health Care
          Read More
          Housing & Development
          Read More
          Talent
          Read More
          Transportation
          Read More
  • Foundation
        • Foundation

          • About
          • Board of Directors
          • Our Funders
          • Upcoming Events
          • Donate
        • ...
          Our Mission
          Expanding Opportunity

          Learn how we advance talent and small business growth.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Foundation Initiatives
          Programming That Empowers

          Explore our key priorities and strategic efforts.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Upcoming Events
          Get Involved

          Join us at our next Foundation event.

          arrow-go
          Read More
  • Join
Bostonchamber
Boston Chamber
  • Become a Member
        • Become a Member

          • Overview
          • Membership Benefits
          • Membership Levels
          • Member Stories
          • Request a Meeting
          • Join Today
        • ...
          About Us
          Get to Know the Chamber

          Discover our mission, values, and leadership.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Member Benefits
          Grow Your Business

          Explore benefits that power your success.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Membership Directory
          Not sure if you’re a member?

          Browse our network of businesses.

          arrow-go
          Read More
  • Events & Networking
        • Events & Networking

          • Overview
          • Upcoming Events
          • Limited Series
          • Chamber Awards
          • Foundation Initiatives
          • FIFA World Cup 2026™
          • Tall Ships – Sail250 
          • MA250  
        • WHAT’S NEXT

          ...
          Upcoming Events
          Engage & Learn

          Explore opportunities to connect and grow.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • FEATURED EVENT

          ...
          Public Policy
          2026 Government Affairs Forum | Ronald J. Mariano, Massachusetts Speaker of the House

          Hear from the Massachusetts Speaker of the House, Representative Ronald J. Mariano (D-Quincy), at the Chamber’s Government Affairs Forum.

          04/09/2026

          9:45am - 11:00am

          Fairmont Copley Plaza Boston

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • EXPLORE OUR PROGRAMMING:

          • Annual & Premier Events
          • Economic Inclusion
          • Small Business & Entrepreneurship
          • Digital Media & Marketing
          • Public Policy
          • Professional Development
          • Women’s Network
          • Workforce Development
          • Young Professionals Network
          • VIEW ALL PROGRAMMING
  • Member Engagement
        • Member Engagement

          • Member Resources
          • Member Deals
          • Sponsorship Opportunities
          • Small Business Benefits
          • Connect with your Member Services Rep
          • Member Spotlights
          • Sign In
        • ...
          Maximize Your Membership
          Register Now

          Take advantage of exclusive perks and programs for members.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Membership Directory
          Discover fellow Chamber members.

          Browse our directory to find and connect with member community.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Upcoming Events
          Stay Involved

          Join experiences that build relationships and spark ideas.

          arrow-go
          Read More
  • Talent & Workforce
        • Talent & Workforce

          • Professional Development
          • Workforce Development
          • Open Programs
          • Insights
        • WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT (FOUNDATION) PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
          City Awake

          City Awake empowers young professionals in a variety of ways that encourages these rising leaders to stay invested in the region’s future success.

          Read More
          Management Crash Course: Core Skills for Modern Supervisors

          Boost your leadership skills with this three‑module professional development series covering adaptive supervision, conflict management, and inclusive decision‑making — with a Certificate of Completion for those who finish the full program.

          Read More
          Massachusetts Apprentice Network

          The Massachusetts Apprentice Network convenes employers, training providers, and talent sources interested in developing and implementing apprenticeship programs in occupations across industries and statewide in fields such as tech, advanced manufacturing, healthcare, financial services, and more.

          Read More
          Strategic Communication for Better Collaboration

          Level up your leadership and communication in this Boston Chamber workshop for professionals—gain essential skills in team alignment.

          Read More
          Partnership with Boston Public Schools 

          The Chamber Foundation invites the business community to engage with Boston Public Schools leaders and their students to help build the future workforce.

          Read More
          Women’s Leadership Program

          Our Women’s Leadership Program enables you to take your leadership to the next level by arming you with the most in-demand leadership toolkit.

          Read More
  • Policy & Impact
        • Policy & Impact

          • Overview
          • Leadership Councils
          • Amicus Advisory Board
          • Government Affairs Forum
          • Eds & Meds Report
        • GET INVOLVED IN OUR POLICY FOCUS AREAS

          Business Climate
          Read More
          Climate & Energy
          Read More
          Health Care
          Read More
          Housing & Development
          Read More
          Talent
          Read More
          Transportation
          Read More
  • Foundation
        • Foundation

          • About
          • Board of Directors
          • Our Funders
          • Upcoming Events
          • Donate
        • ...
          Our Mission
          Expanding Opportunity

          Learn how we advance talent and small business growth.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Foundation Initiatives
          Programming That Empowers

          Explore our key priorities and strategic efforts.

          arrow-go
          Read More
        • ...
          Upcoming Events
          Get Involved

          Join us at our next Foundation event.

          arrow-go
          Read More
  • Join
  • About Us
  • News & Insights
  • Member Directory
  • Job Board
  • Sign In
  • Join

Broker-Dealer Rule Triggers Clash on Beacon Hill

January 8, 2020

A proposal aimed at protecting investors encountered pushback Tuesday from financial services firms and trade groups who argued the changes would instead reduce choice and access for consumers, particularly those with low or moderate incomes.

Secretary of State William Galvin last June proposed a regulation that would apply a fiduciary conduct standard to broker-dealers, agents and investment advisers in interactions with their customers and clients. At the time, Galvin said the move was necessary because a new U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission rule failed to provide investors with the protections they need against conflicts of interest in the financial industry.

My Office has seen firsthand the serious financial harm that investors and savers have suffered as a result of conflicted financial advice, Galvin said in a June statement. Investors must come first.

Galvin’s office said the proposed regulation would deem it an unethical or dishonest conduct or practice for a broker-dealer, agent, investment adviser, or investment adviser representative registered or required to be registered in Massachusetts to fail to act in accordance with a fiduciary duty to any customer or client.

At a hearing Tuesday, commenters said provisions in the regulations would discourage broker-dealers from offering their services in Massachusetts. Several speakers also urged the Securities Division to hold off on new state-level regulations until officials can gauge the impact of the SEC’s new rule, which is known as Regulation Best Interest and takes effect in June 2020.

Greater Boston Chamber of Commerce President and CEO James Rooney described brokerage accounts as a low-cost, low-barrier entry into investing and wealth-building, with advice that is often free and can help people to save for college, retirement or buying a home. He said firms that offer brokerage services may cease to do so, deciding compliance is too difficult or costly.

For those firms that continue to offer brokerage services, the rule proposed in Massachusetts would require that broker-dealers provide the same ongoing advice and guidance as investment advisors, lumping the two into the same category even though they provide different services, Rooney said in written testimony. Under the proposed rule clients will likely be redirected to a more expensive investment advisor model to ensure compliance or face additional fees for the costs of continuous monitoring, creating unnecessary barriers for consumers.

Fidelity Investments’ Pamela Everhart said an estimated 98 percent of low- and middle-income consumers choose to open brokerage accounts to receive point-in-time brokerage advice rather than choosing ongoing advice provided by an investment advisor for a fee.

Kent Mason of the Washington, D.C. law firm Davis and Harman said elements of the proposal would be unworkable for broker-dealers and said the regulatory amendments’ language around avoiding, eliminating or mitigating conflicts of interest is vague.

What’s the difference between avoiding and eliminating? I don’t know, he said. If I can’t avoid it or eliminate it, do I have to mitigate it? I don’t know. If I have to mitigate it, how do I mitigate it? I don’t know. So if someone came to me and said, ‘Should we have brokerage business in Massachusetts,’ I’m a lawyer, I’d say, ‘You’re running an enormous risk because you’ve got a standard that no one understands.’

Galvin’s office, in a small business impact statement dated Dec. 13, said that it’s possible broker-dealers may decide not to open or expand in to Massachusetts if they determine that being held to a fiduciary standard will be too costly or subject them to too much regulatory risk.

The impact statement said that any potential deterrent effect on new business formation would be substantially outweighed by avoiding costs associated with investors receiving conflicted financial advice and the ample and varied sources of financial advice that are already available here.

Individuals and business that seek to provide financial advice, but are unable or unwilling to treat their customers and clients with the appropriate care and loyalty present a substantial risk to investors, the statement said. The potentially catastrophic harm that can result from conflicted advice requires the rigorous approach embodied in the proposed regulations.

AARP Massachusetts, meanwhile, commended the division for its proposal, saying in written comments that all financial professionals who advise retail investors, including both broker-dealers and investment advisors, should be held to a fiduciary standard.

Retail investors are often confused about the fact that there are different types of financial professionals that all could potentially provide similar services, but be held to different standards of conduct, state director Michael Festa and state President Sandra Harris wrote in their testimony. Unlike institutional investors that are aided by their own financial expertise and sophistication, retail investors stand more vulnerable to exploitation by the financial services industry.

There are approximately 900 investment advisors registered in Massachusetts and 1,900 broker-dealers with at least one agent registered in the state, according to the Securities Division.

Read more on StateHouseNews.com.

Footer Logo Foundation Logo

Together, we create a powerful ecosystem that drives
business success, strengthens communities, and enhances
Massachusetts’ long-term competitiveness.

265 Franklin Street
Suite 1701
Boston, MA 02110
Get Directions
Contact us
  • Become a Member
  • Events & Networking
  • Member Engagement
  • Talent & Workforce
  • Policy & Impact
  • Foundation
  • Join
  • About Us
  • News & Insights
  • Member Directory
  • Job Board
  • Sign In
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

© 2026 Greater Boston Chamber of Commerce. All Rights Reserved.

Popular Resources

  • News & Insights  
  • Member Resources  
Close